Leader vs. Boss Part 1: Understanding Organizational Guidance

In the contemporary landscape of organizational dynamics, understanding the difference between a leader and a boss is crucial in determining the success and culture of a workplace. Many individuals interchange the terms. However, guiding your organization as a leader is distinctly different from guiding your organization as a boss. Do you know the difference?

I’m the boss, has a commanding and assertive ring to it. It may even appeal to your dominant personality. But, if you think you are a leader but operate as a boss, then your organization is missing out on the benefits of an effective leader, and you’re missing out on the transformative impact you can have.

A boss is someone in a position of authority and is responsible for managing others and their work. They exercise control over their subordinates. They provide direction and make decisions. Their power comes from their hierarchical position and operate as an authoritarian. Conversely, a leader is someone who takes an organization from where it is towards shared goals through inspiration, motivation, and empowerment.

Why Is It Important to Know the Difference?

Understanding the difference between a leader and a boss is particularly significant in today’s fast-paced, dynamic work environment, where adaptability and innovation are key. Here are three critical metrics that will be different depending if your approach is one of a leader or that of a boss.

• Engagement: Employees engaged at work will deliver more results than those who are disengaged. If you want to maximize engagement, your approach must be that of a leader. That’s because leaders create an environment where their employees feel safe to voice their ideas and opinions. This leads to a culture of collaboration, creativity, and continuous improvement.  Leadership-focused organizations will enjoy greater employee engagement.

• Retention: Corporations spend millions of dollars training and developing their employees. You can understand, then, why retention of their employees is a critical metric. Traditional boss-centric organizations tend to have higher turnover rate than their counterparts where employees feel supported, empowered, and appreciated for what they bring to the table.

• Results: Individuals will deliver more when they feel valued and inspired by their leaders. That’s because they are more likely to engage in driving the business results, contribute creatively, and be committed to the organization’s success. Employees at organizations led by bosses tend to focus on delivering their quota.

It’s imperative to know the difference between the two terms if you aspire to be an effective leader and get superior and sustained results.  The main difference between a leader and a boss is the leader is people-centric and the boss is results-centric.

Boss vs. Leader: Key Points of Difference

Let’s investigate the difference between a boss and a leader.

Power: A leader relies on influence, inspiration, and motivation. That requires prioritizing people, building relationships, and earning respect. In contrast, a boss relies on positional authority to command respect and compliance. This may lead to a culture of fear and low morale.

Focus: Leaders focus on the long-term growth of their businesses and organizations. Bosses focus on task-oriented strategies to deliver today’s results. Oftentimes, these come at the expense of employee retention.

Approach: Leaders are in front pulling the organization with them. They take the initiative to get things done and practice shared leadership with compassion. On the other hand, Bosses push from behind. They tend to stand aside and supervise others doing the work, sometimes through intimidation and the use of ultimatums.

Communication: Leaders actively listen first then speak. They are usually empathetic with a high degree of Emotional Intelligence. While some bosses by nature are good at communication, generally, bosses tend to speak orders and directions first and then may take time to listen.

Growth & Development: Leaders have a growth mindset.  They invest time in developing their direct reports including giving constructive feedback to help them reach their full potential. Bosses, on the other hand, usually have a know-it-all attitude. They manage their employees to deliver targets at all costs. This can include barking orders when results are not on target.

Teamwork: Leaders create a more positive environment by fostering trust, encouraging collaboration, and empowering their people. Leaders accept a team’s failure as their miss and work to put systematic solutions in place. Bosses dictate and assign blame to the one who made the mistake.

For some selective organizations, there may be benefits to a boss-centric culture. While the terms boss and leader may seem interchangeable, their impacts are markedly different.

As organizations strive for success and continuous growth in this increasingly competitive environment, one thing is clear: A focus on leadership rather than an authoritarian culture will result in a healthier and more productive workplace. I’ll share eight steps to grow from a boss to a leader in my next post.

Empowered Leader Reflection

Are there tendencies of a boss approach in your leadership style?

Would you mind sharing your perspective below?

Photo Credit: Pexels.com